Why did judas betray jesus reddit. Jesus even tells him not to waste time and to get it done.
Why did judas betray jesus reddit Full knowledge does not mean full control, and full knowledge does not mean pre-destiny. Judas did what he did, then went and killed himself. Satan understood Judas’ desires and weaknesses and he put evil thoughts into his head and tempted him to betray Christ. I believe every Jewish man in 1st Century Judea had a beard and probably the same haircut, so it makes sense that one who was close to Him needed to identify Him. Judas COULD have made other choices, but Jesus already knew what he WOULD choose. " Jesus said that it would have been better if Judas were never born. It dives into his reasoning for why he betrayed Jesus (plus its great music). But Jesus told Judas He did not come for that. Judas: I’ll do anything. It doesn't justify handing over Jesus to be tortured to death, obviously, but it justifies Judas losing all confidence in him. He could have resisted the devil and prayed for help. If God already knew Judas Iscariot would betray Jesus, then Judas never had a chance. People can be (and often are) influenced or tempted by evil. He didnt make Judas betray Jesus. Feb 13, 2024 ยท jump to content. They didn't resonate. Overtime, Judas hardened his hearted against Jesus and betrayed him. Paul is the one who made that shit up. But none of the apostles, Peter, Judas, James, Matthew or any of the others would have understood Jesus to be divine in any sense during Jesus' life. Democratic Underground is an online community where politically liberal people can do their… 761K subscribers in the AskOuija community. The sign to the authorities was that judas would point him out by kissing him. I understand that this is popular science literature, but still, I saw an interesting thought there: Judas betrayed Jesus because he considered him the future king of the Israelites, and wanted him to finally stop preaching and start leading the people and free Peter and Judas. How did Judas Iscariot die? Matthew 27:3-10 records Judas’s remorse at having betrayed Jesus to the Jewish authorities. God foresaw the future. As the OP rightly noted, in this pericope John clearly states that Jesus gave the bread to Judas (13:26), which is an act Jesus shares only with Judas, and then, moments later, Judas goes to betray Jesus. 1. Its one of the mysteries of the faith but Jesus obviously had knowledge of it. The keyword here being "later". Christ knew that He couldn't have this man The belief I've always understood is that Judas saw how Jesus reacted at the temple and was hoping that if he maneuvered Jesus into a similar situation, he would ignite the Wrath of God mode again. Despite Jesus’s knowledge of the impending betrayal, he did not attempt to stop Judas or retaliate In fact, no one needed to betray Jesus. That was the equivalent of one day soldiers pay at that time. Do I personally (in spite of tradition) think Judas has a glimmer of hope? Yes, I do. it doesn't appear to mean "from eternity past" but more likely "from the beginning of His discipleship". Judas had no choice but to betray Jesus so that the prophecy be fulfilled. He saw Judas betray Jesus. But the Bible doesn’t say just because you betrayed Jesus you lose salvation. He received 30 pieces of silver, a significant amount of money, for his betrayal. This puts in perspective those nay sayers who think God is mean cause He lets people go to hell. Sometimes I wonder if Jesus ordered him to. Jesus is resurrected and Judas is dead. Judas corrupted himself. That makes his free will an illusion, and really means God just used Judas in a suicide-by-apostle scheme. So they weighed for my hire thirty pieces of silver. But Peter also betray Jesus, the difference was that Peter left and “wept bitterly”, or better know as repented. We, like Judas, betray Him and turn away from Him to get temporary pleasure from sin, even though we know its stupid. So what Judas did in itself was supposed to happen by someone. Jesus foreknew that it would happen, but he didnt make it happen. Repentance was not an option. He didnt have to go along. He fulfilled The Subreddit is dedicated to the understanding, discussion of, and loving of The Bible in all its greatness and everything it has to offer. Judas did not betray Jesus - Paul and Mark do not say such a thing. Remember, Judas is not necessarily damned because of what he did. Iscariot means Man from Karioth; it was either an Edomite town in the far south, or a Moabite town across the Jordan River. While other disciples at times made great professions of faith and loyalty (John 6:68; 11:16), Judas never did so and appears to have remained silent. They are NOT the same. Such a kiss is still used in some cultures as a greeting, even among men. " 5 Judas threw the silver pieces into the temple and Which just looks like trying to handwave the problem away. Jesus loved Judas. Before Judas went to the chief priests to betray Jesus, there was a disagreement about wasting perfume. And he allowed it to happen in the course of time. It happened as he said it would. Judas did want to betray, it’s why he did. Judas probably thought Jesus wasn't the Messiah and/or became extremely obsessed with money. Back to the original thought, if Judas had not betrayed Jesus, another disciple would have. By speaking down to Jesus like this Judas proclaimed himself to be higher. Mathew 27 Mathew 16 When Judas, his betrayer, saw that Jesus[a] was condemned, he repented and brought back the thirty pieces of silver to the chief priests and the elders. The non-canon Gospel of Judas suggests that Jesus may have chosen Judas to betray him because Judas loved him the most, fulfilling some aspects of Old Testament sacrificial law. 35 subscribers in the okbuddychristianity community. In other words he didn’t have a chance, as he was quite literally MADE to fail. Another is that he just wasn't on the same frequency as Jesus Christ. God imaged all creation from start to finish in his infinite mind in heaven before creating anything. We never know the lengths of God's mercy. God saved me from a life of drugs and promiscuity,He died to rescue me and He has Jesus Christ is real and everything the Bible says is true! upvotes · comments r/Christianity My personal view (a Methodist one) is that Jesus will be betrayed regardless of whether it is Judas or not, but Judas willingly chose to be the man who betrays the Son of Man. Joseph was one of the 12 sons of Jacob. Judas also had a will and made a choice, thats why he was held accountable and Jesus even felt bad for him, Woe to the one who betrays the son of man, it would have been better for him to never have been born. Jesus was sold and enslaved the Romans. Robert Eisenman believes Jesus had a smaller number of disciples based around So Judas directly betrayed Jesus Christ for money leading to His torture and death. Then said Jesus unto him, That thou doest, do quickly. Jesus let Judas know that he knew about the betrayal, when he gave the bread dipped in wine to Judas. Judas wasn't needed to identify Jesus because they already knew who he was. Judas' betrayal was also prophesied: “And I said unto them, If you think good, give me my hire; and if not, forbear. Investigation of the most high-profile crime in history. Jesus' trial before his crucifixion took many hours and he was tortured and slapped and cursed all through it. What conversation did they have? How did Jesus show his love for Judas then? One can only wonder. And so you illogically think that because Jesus knew Judas would betray him that he made Judas betray him, and of course that's nonsense. Judas did Not have to betray Jesus. He SAW him do that. Judas helped Jesus to fulfil his duties, hence he did not “betray” Jesus in that sense. There are wheat and there are tares. Salvation comes through the death and resurrection of Christ--not through the betrayal and death and resurrection of Christ. I think this is what happened to Judas. In your question, you say 'identify'. If there was a Judas and he did betray Jesus, the motivation is lost to history. The one thing we DO know is that Judas didn't have to betray Jesus Christ. If Judas was created to sin and betray Christ, then he had no free will. Judas chose to be a vessel for Satan. Judas was not necessary for this. The other reason is that the central focus of the story (perhaps I should have left in the 200 word summary) was how a seemingly insignificant event that occurs during the EU4 timeframe, i. Jesus had nothing to do with that choice. One thing is he was greedy, but that doesn't explain why he went to the rulers in the first place. 2-5: "Now Judas, who betrayed him, also knew the place, because Jesus often met there with his disciples. It also implies an ostentatious gesture, and some have interpreted this as Judas kissing Jesus repeatedly. Peter repented, Judas did not. This is what Judas betrayed. Judas may have resented Jesus in some fashion. He asked him to do it, enough said. I do get what you mean. Similarly, when Pakunoda “betrayed” the Phantom Troupe by meeting with Kurapika alone, Chrollo wasn’t mad because he knows that she believes its what’s best for the Phantom Troupe. AskReddit, Ouija-style. But if that's the case, then why exactly did Jesus ask Judas to hand him over to the Pharisees in the gospel of Judas? For what purpose? Judas served a purpose in God’s plan of redemption for humanity. There are children of God and there are children of the devil. He heard the word of God directly from God Himself, yet still chose to reject it. Judas did betray Jesus even if he was a cog in a grander design God didn’t create Judas. " Authors: Bill O'Reilly, Martin Dugard. Jesus was known to go into cities and cause a bit of trouble with His teachings. Only later did it become clear Judas' was hopelessly lost. Hear me out. 5K subscribers in the DemocraticUnderground community. That he may actually die from this. Why did the Jews need Judas to betray jesus? They knew where he was and who he was. Jesus even tells him not to waste time and to get it done. They needed Judas to betray Jesus at an opportune time that they could capture Him in the dead of night which is probably why they would’ve needed Judas to signify which man it was they needed to capture. Later gospels falsely invented story of Judas betraying Jesus for money or under demonic possession. I understand if he doubted he was selling the son of God, which is still about as evil as anyone selling another person that trusts them, but it’s not a cartoonishly, kamikaze type of evil where you’d do it and KNOW with certainty that you’re dooming yourself At one time, though, Judas believed that Jesus was a prophet, or possibly even believed He was the Messiah. But by ''betraying'' Jesus didnt Judas also betray other disciples ,talking about your point that Chrollo believes loyalty is owned to the group if I got you right Interestingly, there are suggestions that the Gnostic sects may well have considered Judas to be a saintly figure. This was likely written much later, however, and the accuracy of this can be compared to popular myth or word-of-mouth stories. Luke and Mark say that Judas was given money, but that Judas offered to betray Jesus first: Mark 14:10-11: In spite of this, Paul believed that the original group of twelve was intact and saw a vision of the risen Jesus (1 Corinthians 15:5). 4 He said, “I have sinned by betraying innocent[b] blood. " 18. John 13:27 KJV — And after the sop Satan entered into Judas. Jesus, despite Judas betrayal is victorious. Judas was included in this group. Bart Ehrman persuasively argues that Judas betrayal consisted of him telling the authorities about Jesus teaching to his disciples that that he would be king (Matt 19:28) Jesus said to them, "Truly I tell you, at the renewal of all things, when the Son of Man sits on his glorious throne, you who have followed me will also sit on twelve thrones If Jesus’ death was a necessity for mankind’s redemption, Judas was predestined from time in memorium to betray the messiah catalyzing his crucifixion, dooming himself to eternal destruction before he ever had in a say in it. ozfwiosiitslxkeiryupnhcebkaawpejozvgfjbwhbecfpsuhijkmaeezxpzrmmhokzvljxpan